Product review: Stevia sweeteners side by side

Posted by: catherine in weight losshealthy cookingfood trendscarbohydrates on Print PDF

catherine

[Three stevia sweeteners reviewed] A "natural" sweetener, Stevia was approved for use in late in 2008 in Australia and the US and the first Stevia products are now appearing on the supermarket shelves.

It's not considered "artificial" and marketing for stevia makes much of it being 100% natural - which appeals to consumers - compared to aspartame or acesulfame-K which are often regarded as "chemical" and can't escape the cancer-scare rumours that have been circulating for years.

 

Background on stevia

Stevia (stee-vee-ah) is derived from the leaves of a sweet plant native to Paraguay in South America. It's 250 to 300 times sweeter than sugar gram for gram but supplies no kilojoules (calories) and does not raise blood sugar. Read about stevia, where it comes from, how it's made, its glycosides that are the active compounds and how it affects your body  in my Articles section.

Glycosides are the active compounds in Stevia that give it its sweet flavour. However there is a slight aftertaste which I pick up and dislike - some people notice and dislike while others don't mind it. To me, it's not the same as sugar but IS way better in taste than the older sweeteners such as saccharin or even aspartame.

 

Stevia - test-driving the products ...

Sweetener No 1

CSR SmartTM White Sugar Blend

csr-smart_sugarThis looks like a regular white sugar but has a tiny addition of stevia powder - only 0.4% steviol glycosides plus 99.6% sugar. Smart™ is twice as sweet as ordinary sugar so you only need to use half as much.

Manufacturer

CSR who market most of the sugar in Australia

Taste 7/10

7/10 relative to ordinary sugar.

You still get an after-taste in the back of your mouth as you swallow. It's slightly liquorice overtone is not unpleasant but is noticable. I sneaked half a teaspoon into my husband's tea without him knowing and he picked it straight away.

Nutrition 7/10

7/10 as it helps dieters to cut their sugar intake by half.
Half a teaspoon (2g) has only 34kJ / 8 cals compared to 65kJ / 15 cals for a teaspoon of sugar.

Ingredients

Sugar 99.6%, sweetener (Steviol Glycosides 0.4%)

On-pack claims

  • "Better for you"
  • "Contains natural ingredients"
  • "50% less calories - twice as sweet so you use half as much"

Convenience 10/10

It looks and tastes exactly like white sugar. You simply use half the quantity you normally use for the same sweetness. Bear in mind that it's expensive - prepare to pay $2 for a 500g pack (which is 40c per 100g) compared with $1.20 for 500g sugar (24c per 100g).

 

Sweetener No 2
PureViaTM stevia sachets

pureviaThese look like the little sachets of Equal® that you spot at cafes as a dieter's alternative to sugar.

Manufacturer

Whole Earth Sweetener company, a subsidiary of Merisant who also manufacturer Equal®.

Taste  6/10

Not as ‘clean' a taste as CSR Smart. On a par with Equal®.

Nutrition 8/10

One sachet (2g) gives you 13 kJ (3 cals) but is equivalent in sweetness to two level teaspoons of sugar at 140kJ (33 cals). It's not pure Stevia - it's a blend of three sweeteners (erythritol, isomaltulose and steviol glycosides), along with flavours plus a cellulose powder bulking agent. The amount of Stevia is so small, it needs the cellulose to make it manageable.

On-pack claims

"PureViaTM, the natural sweetener blend with 90% less kilojoules than sugar, made with the pure, sweet extracts of the Stevia plant. We blend these extracts, known as Steviol Glycosides, with other carefully selected ingredients to give you the smooth, sweet taste of PureVia™."

Convenience 8 out of 10

One PureVia™ sachet (13kJ or 3 cals) is equivalent in sweetness to two level teaspoons of sugar (140kJ).

For some strange reason, they are equivalent to two teaspoons of sugar which is fine if that's the amount you normally add to your coffee or tea but you end up wasting half the sachet if you only want one teaspoon. For dieters, I wouldn't want them getting used to two teaspoons of sugar per cup.

 

Sweetener No 3
Hermesetas SteviaSweetTM

hermesetas-steviasweethermesetas-granularThis comes in three forms - granulated for use in cooking and baking as well as sachets and tablets for coffee and tea.

Manufacturer

Hermesetas who also manufacture sweeteners (saccharin years ago, later aspartame) in tablet and sachet form for many years.

Taste 7/10

7 out of 10 compared to sugar

Nutrition 8/10

The granules are a blend of a starch carrier maltodextrin (53%) together with fructofibres (inulin 34% plus oligofructose 8%) for fibre and the base sweetener steviol glycosides (5%), So it's high in soluble fibres and prebiotic which stimulate the growth of friendly bacteria in the bowel.

On-pack claims

  • "100% natural sweetening ingredient"
  • "90% less calories than sugar"
  • "40% fibre"
  • "Suitable for cooking and baking"
  • "Low Carb / low GI"

Convenience 10/10

The granules are versatile for sweeteneing fruit and desserts as well as coffee and tea. Use cup for cup to replace sugar, so 1 cup sugar = 1 cup SteviaSweet™. The weight is one-tenth the weigh of sugar, so 50g sugar = 5 g Steviasweet™.


 

Your feedback

Have you tried Stevia yet? I'd love to have your feedback on these products. Feel free to leave a comment below.

 

 

Related information

  • Read my review of LowGIcane sugar in the Foodwatch Reviews & Chews section and see whether it would suit you instead of these stevia sweeteners.
  • Want to cut back on your sugar intake? Download my handy Fact Sheet on sugar - where it's hiding, how much is in the everyday foods we love to eat, how much is OK to have, and 4 easy ways to eat less.

 

Comments (17)

Subscribe to this comment's feed
...
0
Thanks for the info. I currently use Stevia and don't mind it at all. Is there any sideffects that you know of??
Jo-Anne , July 15, 2010
...
0
The worst stevia product is better than the best nutra/sacch/sucral product.
Now I've just found out you can make jams and jellies with it! Bam!!!
Ken D Berry MD , January 14, 2011 | url
...
0
AFTER BEING DIAGNOSED AS A TYPE 2 DIABETIC I WENT LOOKING FORA SWEETENER AAND FOUND STEVIA. AFTER READING THAT THE JAPANESE HAVE USED IT ON THEIR TABLES FOR ABOUT 50 YEARS WITH NO SIDE EFFECTS I WAS HOOKED. I FIND NO AFTERTASTE IN THE STEVIA I BUT AND I USE IT FOR EVERYTHING BUT BAKING. HELPS KEEP THE BLOOD SUGAR IN CONTROL WITHOUT GIVING UP SWEET THINGS.
I WROTE A GUIDE AT ABOUT.COM AND SHE DIDN'T CARE FOR STEVIA AS IT WAS PROCESSED BUT LOVED THE CHEMICAL STEWS OF THE ARTIFICIAL SWEETENERS USED IN THE STATES. SHE HAS A MASTERS IN DIET, ETC. I COULDN'T BELIEVE HER ATTITUDE ON THIS SUBJECT.
OH WELL I WILL CONTINUE USING MY STEVIA AS IT WORKS AND AS FAR AS I AM CONCERNED TOTALLY NATURAL.
EMIL PETE PETERSON , March 15, 2011
...
71
Hi Ken & Emil. Thanks for your feedback. Clearly you are both fans of stevia and have found ways to use it in your meals. Both the FDA and the Australian FSANZ have reviewed aspartame twice and given it the OK so this may be why the US dietitian is happy to continue using it. I don't know.

Re natural: The stevia products we tasted were all refined white powders in a packet. In my book, I can hardly call these 'natural' but I know it's extracted from the leaves of a plant. I believe 'natural' is over-used these days. I would only apply the term if I'd picked the stevia leaves, boiled them up into a syrup and used THAT to sweeten my drinks and desserts - see the difference? But no-one has time to do that today! so the debate goes on. Regards Catherine
Catherine Saxelby , March 16, 2011 | url
...
0
The best stevia is 100% pure stevia. Sure it costs more than those products listed above but it is 300 times sweter than sugar, so for example, you only need to use 1/4 of a teaspoon as a substitute for every cup of sugar in baking. That means it last for ages and is cheaper than sugar or all these alternatives. I dislike "Hermesetas Stevia sweet' as the other ingredients (95% of the product!smilies/shocked.gif) leave a bitter after-taste and you have to use the same amounts as sugar anyway, which makes it quite expensive. If you google stevia, there are places to buy the pure stevia in Australia.
Diana Madison , April 08, 2011
...
0
Hmm, these may be good as a starting point for people "addicted" (I use that term loosely) to sugar, and very overweight people, but I do it is possible to "wean" ourselves off added sugars for the most part. Not too say a piece of cake once in a while is going to kill you, but I've "weaned" myself of sugar (not that I was eating that much to start with I suppose) and it's true, your tastebuds really do change and get used to it!
Now for sweetening I use fruit (fresh fruit, dried fruit, as puree or mashed), such as applesauce or date puree instead of sugar in recipes, banana instead of honey, chopped fresh fruit in natural yoghurt instead of "fruit-flavoured yoghurt" and I feel all the much better for it. I don't use honey, molasses, stevia, artificial sweeteners, brown rice syrup, maple syrup, sugar etc, as I still believe that contributes to an overly sweet taste that can become the norm for everyday eating. Plus, why wouldn’t you want all the benefits of fresh dates, bananas etc- who needs added fructofibres when you have it all wrapped up in the natural package of a fresh fig or date, plush heaps of vitamins and minerals as well!
Don't take all this the wrong way; I'm not trying to sound high and mighty, or like a know-it-all, but sometimes I just think all this focus on making things taste "sugary" or taste "fatty" or "carby" without using sugar /fat/carbs is just avoiding the problem; and maybe we need to look at eating whole foods and enjoying natural flavours instead of trying to recreate what nature has already created in a much more nutricious form. Thanks for your website Catherine, I love it! (I am studying this stuff at uni) and enjoy being able to put in my 2 cents smilies/smiley.gif
Sam , April 16, 2011
...
71
Thanks for that tip Diana. Good to have feedback on the taste of which brands taste good and which don't. The Hermesetas is "bulked out" with starch and fibre so a cook can simply swap the amount of sugar for the SAME amount of the stevia product. Not ideal but makes it easy for measuring out.

Sam, yes all sweeteners are a way to wean yourself off sugar but they still allow people to retain their "sweet tooth". I like your approach of using fruit and fruit purees to sweeten things lightly and with less "sugariness". Thanks for the tip. And glad you like the website. Good luck with your studies. Cheers Catherine
Catherine Saxelby , April 19, 2011
...
0
I was diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes in Jan 11 and I have tried the Hermesetas Stevia from Woolworths and also tried Hermesetas Granulated Sweetner Low GI but I am concerned about the Phenylalanine content which the Hermesetas Stevia from Wollies do not have. Both good size bottles that last a long time for just me. Also there is Natvia natures sweetener but comes in a 200g container. Have purchased on but not used it yet. Probably wont last long and it costs more than the other two mentioned.

When the Hermesetas Granulated Sweetner runs out, I'll used up the Natvia and then go back to the Woolies Hermesetas Stevia.

Which is the best one to use?

Thanks.
Phillip Webb , November 06, 2011
...
0
Not a fan at all of Hermesetas Stevia sweet for baking. Awful aftertaste and didnt mix well. Felt like a science experiment rather than a food. Im not convinced and since Im not overweight and not a big sugar consumer I would be more comfortable with raw sugar or honey in my baking.
Shannon Barry , December 03, 2011 | url
...
0
I just did a taste test on PureVia cubes v Hermesetas Stevia Sweet tabs, and the PureVia tasted much better in tea. More or less exactly the same as sugar with tiniest aftertaste which was not unlike sugar anyway.

By comparison, the Hermesetas tasted much like any other sweetner. I couldn't believe it is basically the same stuff.

Purevia cubes were about 5 times the price though (per 'teaspoon').
Matt Langley , February 08, 2012
...
71
Thanks for your taste test findings Matt. Interesting that you found the PureVia cubes so good in taste. We only did the little sachets so there may be a difference due to that.
Catherine Saxelby , February 12, 2012
...
0
Might also be worth giving SweetLeaf a try. They are only 1 of a handful of Stevia manufacturers that produce Stevia with zero GI. They also offer an interesting range of Stevia Liquid flavours that you can experiment with.
Justin , March 14, 2012 | url
...
0
Hermesetas stevia tablets...even with 5 in my tea there was no sweet taste...I contacted the company but no reply.
adrian , April 01, 2012
...
0
Don't like the Hermesetas Stevia Sweet. It is bitter, in fatc you might as well use nothing.
Won't be using it again
Simon Bell , April 05, 2012
...
0
I never test stevia but I would like to test it can you tell me is it 100% pure "stevia". also is it good for health. Thanks..
Bipul D. , April 21, 2012 | url
...
0
I have tried the Hermesetas stevia from Woolies for cooking & do not like the after taste. It`s bitter I won`t be buying that anymoresmilies/sad.gif
Dianne , May 09, 2012 | url
...
0
I am also not a fan of Hermesetas Stevia Sweet! For some reason I bought it without checking it's ingredients and am completely disappointed with what is in it (only 5% Stevia Glycosides), not too mention the awful after taste you get. I also wont be using it again.
sue x. , May 11, 2012

Write comment

smaller | bigger

busy